Why did he kill himself? Answering the why

charles-wilderness-04-23-12-CR

Charles in Wilderness Program for troubled teens. It was here that we finally got a great diagnosis. He did embrace the program after 4 weeks or so.

I learned a lot about Charles after his death by suicide from his RAP diary where he wrote his songs. You can see his notebook in his hands in the picture on this page. Many of his friends know what I’m talking about since he carried them with him. They were his lifeline.

It’s in those pages I saw just how much he hurt. Every single day.

And why he ultimately gravitated to heroin as it was the only time he got a break from his pain since he suffered from insomnia and DSPS since he was a toddler.

It was a struggle for him to choose to live every day. And I know he lived for everyone else.  But it meant he chose to stay with us as long as he did.

These are his original lyrics which he hand wrote. He didn’t edit, they just poured onto paper out of his head in a a stream of consciousness style. Pretty amazing really.

Till now, I’ve not shared any of his work that he had not published. It’s like I’m tearing something precious from my heart. But I feel it’s too selfish to keep to myself and I know he wanted his lyrics to touch others who hurt and understood their pain. He always touched other young people who also suffered from depression.

This is what teen depression sounds like, looks like. See Charles’ other rap songs posted on this site here.

Just to Hurt 

by Charles Aubrey Rogers, Reezin the Revolutionary, April 26, 1995-June 5, 2015

Back in another institution,
Guess I’m stupid, feeling useless even though my music tight as a noose is
Every day is a nuisance
Bored as fuck I want to do shit
Guess I didn’t learn my lesson.
Been in treatment most of my adolescence.*
Drug cravings, anxiety and depression
All because of my obsession
I know I’ll get by
But all rehab does is make me wanna get high
I bet God sits in the sky wishing I’d just die
They said I got amazing potential if I’d just try
Since I was 15 I’ve been fed lies
Said I’d be gone for 2 weeks I was gone for 3 years. What the hell why?**
This is my life, That was my time, I can never get it back
That wasn’t yours to take from me
But this is life and there ain’t no pot of gold after the rainbow
But there’s pain through
I promise you there’s pain yo

(chorus)

Why we put on here on this earth just to hurt, just to hurt, just to hurt
So much pain in the universe

They said it’s gonna get worse before it gets better
But all I see is hurt and its been getting worse forever
It always seems to rain the most when I’m promised perfect weather
And if you’re hurt too, then we can hurt together

I put these words together, pain stain in every letter
Cause me and Cal used to hangout, before he decided to hang down**,
Heroin took a home from me
He found a place in the ground
I scream for God to answer but he ain’t make a sound

My demons up against me and I’m facin’ them now
I wear the face of a clown
I feel so unloved, because of the monster that was created from drugs

(chorus)
Why we put on here on this earth just to hurt, just to hurt, just to hurt
So much pain in the universe

I hope this last verse sticks in ya mind momma
I promise Imma fix it this time
I’m putting it behind cause I can’t forgive myself
And you can’t give me back time

My emotions drip through these lines
But even in darkness sunshine sometimes shines through the blinds
You were paying for hope and I was lookin’ for dope
Cause I just couldn’t cope
And I’m just so afraid that I’ll end up alone

I’ll always miss my own home
I always seem to fuck things up
I guess rock bottom wasn’t deep enough
Even breathing’s tough

It’s like I’m surrounded by walls with no escape at all
I’m over 6 feet tall, But I’ve never felt so small

(chorus)
Why we put on here on this earth just to hurt, just to hurt, just to hurt
So much pain in the universe

—————-

*Charles spent 10 weeks in a Wilderness program and 15 months in a therapeutic boarding school

**We sent Charles away to these programs to figure out what was the matter, local resources being very weak. We did it to save his life and to see if he could learn to manage his illness. Although diagnosed with depression, he never admitted it. Too much stigma. 

***Charles knew Cal Riley who hung himself 2 years before Charles did. This haunted Charles. They met in wilderness and became very close. Never in the history of that decades-old program in Clayton Georgia, did two kids from the same high school (Cosby High School) end up in the same wilderness group

Published by

AnneMoss Rogers

AnneMoss Rogers is a mental health speaker and suicide education trainer and consultant. She is author of the Book, Diary of a Broken Mind and co-author of Emotionally Naked: A Teacher's Guide to Preventing Suicide and Recognizing Students at Risk with Kim O'Brien PhD, LICSW. She raised two boys, and lost her younger son, Charles, to addiction and suicide on June 5, 2015. She combines lessons learned from her experience with proven strategies to help organizations build a wellness culture that drives results and saves lives. She speaks at conferences as a keynote, at workplaces,and at K-12 schools and universities.

20 thoughts on “Why did he kill himself? Answering the why”

    1. I know. The drugs and alcohol had kept him falsely buoyant. Well if not buoyant it numbed his pain. By the end of wilderness he was proud of himself and his accomplishments. This however was not my proudest moment. I am not sure if anything would have worked. But we had to try. Support back then was thin. And two professionals recommended this step. Had he died right after NOT taking it I would still have blamed myself. Which I no longer do because it’s a dilemma with few right answers and a lot of possible wrong turns and regrets.

  1. How long did it take you to be able to truly function? My son hung himself on the campus of WSU APRIL 13,2023. He was a Bio-engineering major, getting 4.0 in all classes, incredibly talented, so funny, artistic, musical inclined and so much more. Teddy (Theodore) was really incredible but a girl lead him to a darkness he couldn’t get out of. She was his first love but she didn’t reciprocate the same feelings if anything she kinda used him to satisfy her own needs. I don’t hold any fault on her I’m certain she faults herself enough.
    I just can’t seem to get past the fact he is never coming home. I sent him to college and it feels like he is still there. I’m just waiting for him to come home He only had 3 weeks to finish his freshman year he was only 19, he had his first kiss only 2 weeks before he died and told me every detail of it. I will treasure that memory he was so sweet and happy. He died a pure boy. He left a 3 page letter which was almost lyrical. Like your son me wrote music. I have several songs he wrote that truly express his feelings. They say a lot, about the girl and his father.
    I’m just wondering when I can possibly truly breathe again.

    Kindly,
    Kathleen, mama of TeddyFE19

    1. I am so sorry. It’s so painful and difficult and it depends but I can say it took me 2 years and really three before I felt part of the human race again. It was in and out like a radio signal for a while.

      No one dies by suicide for one reason alone. Those relationship disruptions like the one your son experienced might have been a final straw event that pushes him toward his end, he had to be vulnerable to suicide prior to that. Family history of mental health issues maybe, certainly transition from high school to college which is a big one and other factors I cannot name. I can say with certainty it was not because you did not love enough. The pain you feel now is testament to the love you felt towards your son. Like me you feel like a truck ran over you not just your heart which I know is crushed.

      Really the grief process is about learning to live without the one you love on earth. It’s learning to integrate grief into your life as you will always live without that. And finally your relationship with your beloved dead, your son, will evolve over time. I still talk to my son. In my head and even out loud sometimes. (Thank god for earbuds or peoples would think me crazy)

      Much love to you. And I hate this happened to you. What are you doing for you? For support?

  2. My uncle suicide I was 7 thanx very deep poetry so sorry loss I’m 38 Now still struggling depression addiction daily bless you

    1. The ripple effect from a death by suicide is so profound. I know support groups and talking about it and writing a lot has helped me. It doesn’t remove the pain but it does help me manage it and work through it. Thank you for talking about your uncle.

  3. Thank you for sharing Anne. Right now, as I text, I am trying to find the words to comfort my son whose friend tragically passed from an overdose this past weekend. He says he’s tired of losing friends – and I’m at a loss as to how to help.
    You sharing your words, Charles’s words, mean so much to me, I pray they touch other lives.

    1. I have grief resources on the page resources > grief. I am so sorry. It is hard. I do want someone his age to write a post or do a video on what it’s like to lose so many friends. It’s devastating. As a mom, do thank him for telling you about his grief and being open on the subject of talking about his friends. That will keep him talking. It’s silence and stoicism that is the most worrisome.

  4. Anne, I am always so deeply touched by your sharing, and by the words Charles wrote. He was a gifted writer for sure and clearly had an open heart for others like his mom.

    1. Anne,
      I understand. I had so many messages like these. I went long periods of time not answering at all. It’s an insanity that can not be understood unless you have been through it. Reading the text messages made me feel faint. I would get weak in the knees and could barely function. There is just no way of knowing how to respond. You were and are a good mom. I’m so sorry that your son didn’t make it out of this terrible disease alive. Forgiveness is so important! The pain isn’t discussed enough. Thank you for being so raw and transparent in your writing.

  5. Anne Moss, I am hurting for you. My nephew, who is somewhere on the streets right now, has lived a very difficult life. Having several diagnoses and on meds since he was young, he has been in and out of drug treatment programs, on several occasions he attempted to take his life by overdosing (maybe cries for help because he was never successful), and in and out of jail, even prison. I can relate to many of the lyrics in this rap by Charles. I am encouraged by your willingness to lay it all out there in an effort to help others in their struggles. May God bless you and keep you. <3

    1. Thank you for sharing your struggles Cheryl. I lets everyone, me included, know we are not alone.

  6. Let the river of these Names take you…
    Let yourself float in the beauty of your own heart
    into the ocean of Love that fills all space,
    that ALWAYS is…
    that ONLY is.
    When we know ourselves to be That,
    then we can be This too.
    Then we can play,
    We are free and bound in the same breath,
    The breath of the One breathes in us…
    It’s OK to be messed up, to feel small and sad and hurt
    with no hope of ever seeing a good day.
    It’s OK to forget, to be forgotten,
    to be left behind,
    It’s OK to be betrayed, strung out on everything
    that everyone has ever done to us and we can’t ever forgive…
    Because
    The breath of the One breathes in us.
    Breathes us.
    Even when we don’t know..
    (Listen to this with your heart.) ♡

  7. My fiancé committed suicide 1 year and 9 days ago, he shared a similar story. I ask myself every single day.. why?.. he never left a note. He left us nothing. Something about suicide cuts deeper than anything imaginable.. and I don’t think the pain ever leaves even though I’ve been told it gets better.. I’m still waiting for that.. I knew your son, he was really talented.. he was deep, so was Walt. I think his thoughts ate him alive inside. Both of them. They shared a similar talent, they could rap better than anyone i knew but it stemmed out of this deep pain from inside themselves, this demon that wouldn’t rest.. I want you to know, he watches over me, my Walt, I know he does. It sounds crazy, but I don’t care anymore, your son is still with you. He keeps you safe too, he’s learning lessons on the other side while we learn our lessons here…. I’ve been slowly realizing that our realities are so different now. The lines of safety and security (two things I worry most about) begin to fade in the afterlife.. it’s different.. I know it’s frustrating having all these unanswered questions, trust me I do.. It’s hard to move forward (and then back again) It’s hard to not get hung up every day over them.. I do know one thing is for sure though.. Now they don’t battle demons anymore, they don’t lose sleep or have night terrors anymore, the fear is gone for them, they are safe. They don’t hurt in those ways anymore. That’s the beautiful part.

  8. Thank you so much for being so brave and sharing your loss with all of us.
    My children loved your son.
    I loved him too.
    He shared some of his lovely poetry with us.
    He will live in our hearts forever.
    Continue the bravery.
    We support you.

    1. Thank you, thank you. Miss him so very much. He had so much left to say. Now it’s up to me to help send his message

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap